opinion articles

Send us a link

Subscribe to our newsletter

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Preprints

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Preprints

Many biologists are still reluctant to submit preprints, in part out of concern that doing so will allow others to “scoop” their work and undermine their chances of publication in a prestigious journal. I would like to rebut that concern, among others, and to share our research group’s first experience submitting a preprint manuscript.

When Will Peer Reviewers Finally Get Paid?

When Will Peer Reviewers Finally Get Paid?

Right now, the overwhelming majority of peer reviewers, the scientists who scrutinize the latest studies, aren't paid for their labor. This is completely ridiculous. Peer review may be the most important part of the scientific enterprise, and it is not incentivized monetarily.

Scientists Should Be Solving Problems, Not Struggling to Access Journals

Scientists Should Be Solving Problems, Not Struggling to Access Journals

It takes an average of 15 clicks for a researcher to find and access a journal article. This time could be much better spent

Billionaires Are Rushing into Biotech. Inequality Is Following Them into Science

Billionaires Are Rushing into Biotech. Inequality Is Following Them into Science

In this era of billionaires and unequal funding, where is research going? And perhaps more importantly, how will our changing resources affect the training, success, and diversity of the scientists of our future?

Linking Impact Factor to 'Open Access' Charges Creates More Inequality in Academic Publishing

Linking Impact Factor to 'Open Access' Charges Creates More Inequality in Academic Publishing

Simply adding an ‘open access’ option to the existing prestige-based journal system at ever increasing costs is not the fundamental change publishing needs, says Bianca Kramer and Jeroen Bosman 

Six Questions About Openness in Science

Six Questions About Openness in Science

Transparency is especially important because science appears to be facing a major credibility crisis right now. The high percentage of bronze OA means that many papers are vulnerable to being re-enclosed. Librarians have failed to make institutional repositories either interesting or useful. The rise of pay-to-publish gold OA is a real problem, especially for less wealthy countries.

Why It’s Hard to Prove Gender Discrimination in Science

Why It’s Hard to Prove Gender Discrimination in Science

Lack of transparency and unconscious biases make it hard to spot inequality.  Scientists pride themselves on objectivity, and may, therefore, be slow to see how unconscious biases alter their judgment and actions.

Repeat Offenders: When Scientific Fraudsters Slip Through the Cracks

Repeat Offenders: When Scientific Fraudsters Slip Through the Cracks

Balancing due process with the academic community's right to know is no easy task, but critics say more could be done to weed out bad actors.  Many universities halt investigations after an accused scientist departs, leaving future employers blind to the researcher’s history of allegations.

Open-Access Model Is a Return to the Origins of Journal Publishing

Open-Access Model Is a Return to the Origins of Journal Publishing

Until recently, many university and society journals operated at a loss. To return to their earlier significant role in scientific dissemination, scientific societies and universities will have to return to their earlier acceptance of knowledge sharing as part of their broader public service, rather than their more recent exploitation of publications as revenue generators.

Conflicting Academic Attitudes to Copyright Are Slowing the Move to Open Access

Conflicting Academic Attitudes to Copyright Are Slowing the Move to Open Access

The open access movement has prompted a shift towards retention of rights and the use of creative commons licenses to control how works are used by publishers. However, in many cases, researchers continue to agree to standard assignment terms offered by publishers without fully investigating or understanding them.

A Beginner's Guide for Addressing Sexual Harassment in Academia

A Beginner's Guide for Addressing Sexual Harassment in Academia

Suggestions for how scientists, specifically male scientists, can undermine the alienating culture of sexual harassment that exists in STEM.

Funding for Fundamental Research Is Under Threat

Funding for Fundamental Research Is Under Threat

The US now faces a dilemma over the future of this national achievement and the supporting arrangements making it sustainable. The ‘social contract’ for science and research now looks more tentative than at any time since the Space Race.

All Science Should Inform Policy and Regulation

All Science Should Inform Policy and Regulation

In the context of a recent proposal to exclude research from consideration at the Environmental Protection Agency, John Ioannidis points out that "perceived perfection is not a characteristic of science, but of dogma" and envisions how governments can promote a standard of openness in science.

Star Wars: Who Should Get Credit for Solving the Mystery of Gravitational Waves ?

Star Wars: Who Should Get Credit for Solving the Mystery of Gravitational Waves ?

When scientists in California and around the world finally solved the mystery of gravitational waves last year, only one question remained: Who should get credit for the discovery?

Considering the 'Leaky Pipeline'- Are We Missing the Point on Leadership Diversity?

Considering the 'Leaky Pipeline'- Are We Missing the Point on Leadership Diversity?

There's a great deal of concern about a lack of diversity in senior academic roles. But Rachel Handforth's research suggests that problems start much earlier along the academic career path.

Beneficiaries of Organisation IDs Must Be Willing to Invest in Them

Beneficiaries of Organisation IDs Must Be Willing to Invest in Them

Collecting, annotating and curating data of universities, funding organizations and publishers manually is both wasteful and impossible to do comprehensively. If these data were available in a globally standardized, digital, open format, this effort could be redirected towards analysis and improving research information and administration.

Why Media Should Rethink the Way It Covers Science

Why Media Should Rethink the Way It Covers Science

Across time, public understanding about how science works is affected by journalism. A journalist, with very little extra effort, can increase the accuracy of public understanding and minimize public vulnerability to distortions of science.

Opium in Science and Society: Numbers

Opium in Science and Society: Numbers

We call for bringing sanity back into scientific judgment exercises. Despite all number crunching, many judgments - be it about scientific output, scientists, or research institutions - will neither be unambiguous, uncontroversial, or testable by external standards nor can they be otherwise validated or objectified.